The rantings of a Public Defender constantly fighting against society's pervasive Police Industrial Complex. Enjoy the unique perspective of one whose life's work is to fight the system through the system.

Tuesday, June 28, 2005

Idiotic Gang Experts/Allegations

I've written before about how idiotic I find cop "expert" opinions frequently are. I basically feel that these are political positions masquerading as some kind of strong science. Police and prosecutors put up these silly opinions all the time to "educate" the jury about certain crimes. As the crimes have become more plentiful, and as the level of activity that will allow you to be considered violating that crime increases, and as the number of silly enhancements have increased, so have the number of times in which police officer "opinion" testimony comes in.

Let me give you a little hint - police officer opinion testimony is always that the person charged is guilty - their opinion as to some area of their "expertise" will always conform with that opinion, always, no matter what the circumstances.

Someone has a single joint - could be possessed for sale. The police saw him smoking it? Still could be possessed for sale. He said he wasn't selling? Drug dealers frequently lie, he still could be possessing for sale. They didn't see him do anything consistent with selling? Drug dealers are cagey people, he still could be possessing it for sale, and therefore, the officer still has that opinion, and the jury hears a "respected" member of law enforcement give them the opinion as to the ultimate issue in that case, whether it was possessed for sale, that is almost impossible to disprove (how do you disprove a negative?).

But in the area of gangs it has become even more absurd. Proposition 21, the "Juvenile Justice" bill (put in quotes here because much of the law it changed had nothing to do with juvenile law), made any crime committed for the purpose of a gang a strike. Paint your nickname on a wall, not only did it just turn into a felony (as long as someone can say it costs $400 to paint over), but it is also a strike. Pick up any new petty theft the future and you may get 25 to life (if you painted 2 walls, that is, and got 2 strikes). It gets even worse, though. When giving their testimony about gangs, police are able to bring in any unfavorable character evidence against the defendant that they want, and not just against the defendant, but also against any of his friends, family, acquaintances, etc (they may all be in the gang, after all).

So now, just about any innocuous offense can be alleged to be committed "for the benefit of the gang," no matter how non-gang related it really is. Have a gun? Possessed for the gang. Have some drugs? Possessed for the gang. Write a bad check? Did it for the gang. Slap your wife? Did it for the gang. Rob a bank? Did it for the gang.

And now, no matter how weak a case is against any particular defendant, even if the person is really innocent, the jury will hear all of this terrible character evidence - much of it not even related to the particular defendant but to his acquaintances, that will prejudice them against him even further, working to prevent him from getting a fair trial on the particular facts of the case.

And worse of all, the DA now won't dismiss these idiotic gang allegations once filed. So, even if you have someone who is guilty of possessing that gun, or having a couple of joints, or writing that bad check, or scratching their name into the bus bench, they must now plead to a strike to resolve their case or go to trial and face the mountain of bad character evidence that will be introduced against them, all ensuring that no jury will ever give them a fair shot.

This is the daily level of idiocy from police and prosecutors we have to deal with. I'm not saying my clients are angels, believe you me. But, they deserve a fair shot in life without having a pre-paved highway to life in prison being set out before them by the time they're 18 years old. Give these people a shot, because, believe me, if you don't give people a shot, they will be far more likely to take one at you.


Anonymous Nicola said...

Admitedly I am not a lawyer of any kind - and I am also british, but it occurs to me that there is perhaps a way to deal with this.

In the example given ask the police officer the differnces between someone possessing for sale and possessing for thier own use. Or perhaps just ask them to state the things usually found in someone possessing for thier own use - then the police officer will be condemned from his own mouth. You will be able to say something like - so in reality what you are saying is that he shows all the indications of possessing for his own use, or so you can't actually see any difference in the two types of possession.

Can you please tell me why that approach wouldn't work?

6/30/2005 2:55 PM

Blogger 7472 said...

Not what I was searching for, but none the less and interesting blog here. Thanks for putting it up. I've enjoyed reading alot of the text here. I got you bookmarked for the future, I'll be back.

My site is a bit different, some think it's odd. I guess it's a matter how you look at it. I have a mens male enhancement reviews related site. Most of the articles are on mens male enhancement reviews.

10/01/2005 6:35 PM

Anonymous Anonymous said...

mobile home sales southern california
Information => mobile home sales southern california

10/03/2005 3:58 PM

Blogger Quit Smoking said...

Hi, I was looking around some blogger blogs for some ideas to start my own on ebooks and you have given me some great ideas. Good blog. I will check it out every week. Thanks

10/03/2005 10:22 PM

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you! I have a computer und internet site/blog. It pretty much covers computer und internet related stuff.

10/04/2005 7:24 AM

Blogger Jack Naka said...

Nice blog. Please check out my fashion sketch site. It is all about fashion sketch informations.

10/05/2005 2:13 AM

Blogger hiro said...

Cool blog you have going here, I will check in often! I have a similar site about estate planning lawyer. It pretty much covers estate planning lawyer related stuff.

10/06/2005 9:13 AM

Blogger hiro said...

Just thought i would say hi from Japan. Doing some blog surfing and found your site. Im looking for some cool styles of florida injury lawyer for my own blog. Theres some really amazing blogs about. if you have time check out my site you will find information on florida injury lawyer. Well when i get my blog running hope you come and check it out.

10/06/2005 12:03 PM

Blogger Nick Bravo said...

You the educated individual has confirmed what I suspected. Great Blog!

1/17/2006 12:03 PM

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Your blog is typical "public defender" material....shallow. You obviously don't know gangs and gang culture. The information you provide on Prop 21 is also lacking. Show how it changed Prop 184, show why it was placed on the ballot in the first place...and on and on....

4/14/2010 6:50 PM

Blogger gman said...

Just surfed in. I agree with the anonymous asshole that this is "typical public defender material." Except from me its a compliment. Stay in the fight.

Seems like the guy missed the point of what you said though. I wonder what he claims as a basis for knowledge of "gangs and gang culture." He should meet Judge Villar, who has a brother who (allegedly) is a former gang member. He goes by Villaraigosa and he has a bitchin job.

1/27/2011 6:08 PM

Anonymous viagra online said...

Wow nice reasearch, unfortunately the world works like that, that's why everyone must look for the own place for each one and just try to be happy, remember that the money don't buy happiness, but it helps a lot.
Thanks, good luck.

1/31/2011 6:19 AM

Anonymous Generic Viagra said...

i lawyer all of you are the scum who rottens this society, I wonder why you chose this dirty career.

6/01/2011 10:06 AM

Anonymous Cheap Viagra Online said...

Your article is actually really clearly composed as well as easily understandable. Your current Blog theme is impressive as well! Would be awesome to discover exactly where My partner and i are able obtain it.Please keep up the excellent work

10/06/2011 3:15 PM


Post a Comment

<< Home