Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Another Update on William Richards, FVI00826 - Actual Innocence is a Sham

I posted more than a year ago about an excellent granting of a habeas corpus petition by Judge Brian McCarville. The defendant is William Richards. His case number is FVI00826. The essence of the case is that he was accused of murdering his wife by bashing her head in. After three mistrials, he was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. Then he was able to obtain favorable DNA evidence, and show that there were serious with the evidence presented against him at his trial. I mean, serious. Like, they framed him. Oh, and an expert that was hot and heavy against him kind of fully recanted his testimony and/or it was all shown to be BS. Mostly anyway. One of the few times it has happened, and certainly the only time that I have seen it, Judge McCarville granted the habeas corpus petition. It is CERTAIN that if he is retried, he cannot be convicted. Not with what we now know.

Then, on 11-19-2010, the California Court of Appeal wrote and unpublished decision REVERSING Judge McCarville's excellent opinion. Appelleate Court Justice Hollenhorst wrote the opinion, and he was joined by McKinster and Richli. All three are right wing Republican tools. The opinion is as terrible as it is disingenuous. Here is my summary of the opinion:

Too bad, so sad. We don't believe your new "evidence." You may have fooled Judge McCarville, but you won't fool us. This new "evidence" should have been brought forward at trial, and in fact some of it was. So it isn't really new "evidence." And the jury didn't believe the defense then, so, again, too bad, so sad. Oh, and just because someone who is crucial to your conviction is later found to be a complete liar and kind of, sort of, mostly admits it, to some extent or another, again, too bad, so sad. You lose. Yeah, we suppose that "actually innocent" people are kind of, sort of entitled at least to a new trial. But not your guy. Oh, and did I mention that we think your new "evidence" isn't very good? Oh, and Judge McCarville didn't apply the correct standard. We could tell you the correct standard, but we are pretty busy up here, denying all your silly motions. The standard is something like: The new evidence must undermine the prosecution's entire case and unerringly point towrd his innocence. We realize this is an impossible standard, but we're going to hold you to it. Oh, and stop spending so many days on these stupid hearings for murderers, Judge McCarville - we're just going to crap on whatever you rule on anyway.

Oh, and there were a LOT of case citations - I'll spare you those. I suppose that I shouldn't get too indignant over this local travesty of justice, but I can't help myself. Let me clarify: I KNOW Judge McCarville. He isn't some bleeding heart liberal. He calls them mostly like he sees them, but like most judges in this county, he is pro-prosecution. Remember, they are all elected, and they don't get re-elected by letting people charged with crimes go free. If Judge McCarville spends the time to do a habeas corpus petition and grants it, you had better damned sure believe that that was the right thing to do.

The case is currently before the California Supreme Court. I don't expect the Court to reverse the Appellate Court. I have just about zero faith in the California Supreme Court on criminal justice issues. They are a mostly zombie-controlled, Republican-appointed bench. I met the Chief Justice recently and she seemed nice, but she is another former prosecutor plucked from convicting people and put on the bench. Some of the justices aren't too bad. I like some of Justice Kennard's opinions. Justice Werdegar too, sometimes. The newest Justice, who hasn't been confirmed yet, Goodwin Liu, is promising. But he is just one guy. I am giving the California Supreme Court short shrift here because they have written some awful opinions in the criminal defense world for about 16 years now, when Rose Bird was forced off the bench. If they reverse the 4th Circuit, Division 2, I will be amazed. I will personally sing their praises. But I fully expect them to follow Justice Scalia's dissent (joined by Justice Thomas) in In re Davis (2009) 130 S.Ct. 1, wherein Scalia stated: "This Court has NEVR held that the Constitution forbids the execution of a convicted defendant who has had a full and fair trial but is later able to convince a habeas court that he is "actually innocent."

In other words: Fuck you. We don't care how "actually innocent" you may be. So long as you got a "fair trial," you will be punished. Period. Finality is king. Never mind whether witnesses recant their testimony. Who cares? By the way, the remedy in the Troy Davis case was to remand the case back to the district court for a new habeas petition, which everyone agreed was without any power. Said petition was promptly denied, and the denial was then affirmed by the Eleventh Circuit. Troy Davis is now getting closer to execution. He got his "actual innocence hearing," and he got to call various witness that showed 9 of 11 witnesses who testified against him at trial recanted their testimony. 9 of 11? Really? Would 10 of 12 have done the trick? How about if all 11 had recanted? The U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear the Mr. Davis's appeal from the habeas petition denial. Here is a good discussion of where Troy Davis is at now:

The lesson here? Don't get convicted the first time. Because if you do, even if you can later prove you were actually inocent, to just about ANY degree of certainty, so long as you got a "fair trial," you're guilty. Period.

Dennis R. Wilkins

Oh, and I suppose that I am now the New PD Dude.


Sean Mong said...

barbados holidaysdenial angerLooks like we're not the only ones outraged. Plump slammed her golden desk, causing paper to fly everywhere. In some ways, this place reminded me of Plump's class.

"Mirror, mirror, quit your lies, tell me how, or you shall die!" Demanded Plump, her face boiling with anger.

I think that's a little too harsh, even if the mirror is being extremely rude. However I must say, it's really flattering having someone on your side. I rarely do, it's just the same people. For once, Plump is on our side, backing us up. Now that's something!

Unknown said...

So apparently finding a reliable custom dissertation writing sercice is not easy. I read on your blog on this and I figured finding one would be pretty easy since there aren’t so many online. I was wrong. Help me by recommending one or two such sites.

Unknown said...

in each blog do not necessarily provide a quality article but here I could find that I was looking for thanks
jaket kulit sukaregang

Unknown said...

in each blog do not necessarily provide a quality article but here I could find that I was looking for thanks
jaket kulit sukaregang

jual jaket kulit asli said...

blogs that provide quality information and can be reperensi for us all thank you admin

distributor jaket kulit said...

the info in this blog gives a good note and make visitors feel at home visiting the blog this one

produsen jaket kulit said...

the article notes that provide information of interest to visitors and make this blog became famous on the internet

produsen jaket kulit

Unknown said...

be a reflection and a lot of knowledge to visit this blog and interesting to read thanks admin, my site can visit jaket kulit garut much koleksi leather jacket.

Unknown said...

My public defender gave me a look of disapproval and said, “You were on ... When I got back to the holding cell, the other guys were already talking about it. dissertation corp uk

Anonymous said...

many places to add useful knowledge, such as a visit to this website thank you admin..jaket kulit murah visit my website

Shppers time said...

Call Girls in Goa

Goa escort Service

escort service in Goa

massage girls in goa

indian girls in goa

Russian girls in goa

goa hot girls

goa sexy girl

escorts in Goa

Call Girls in Bangalore

Female Escort in Bangalore

Escort Agency in Bangalore

Bangalore Russian Escorts

Bangalore Female Escorts

Bangalore escorts

Bangalore Escorts Service

Independent Escorts in Bangalore

Independent Bangalore escorts

Bangalore escort

Escort in Bangalore

Bangalore Call Girl

Escorts in Bangalore

Bangalore Escort Girls

Bangalore Escorts Agency

Sky Lark Squad said...

computer support//
tech support//
virus removal Support//
windows support//
apple support//
spyware removal Support//
online tech support//
email Support//
email Support Phone Number//
Microsoft windows support//
it support//
Quick Books Support//
Antivirus Support//
microsoft computer support//
||microsoft computer support phone number//
||microsoft support//
||microsoft support phone number//
||microsoft laptop support//
||microsoft laptop support number//
||microsoft office support//
||microsoft office support phone number

Tamika baden said...

Best Zoho HR management software in Pakistan, UAE, KSA, and Bahrain.

Cheap HR Software

Benjamin James said...

Quite A Beautiful Website. We Are Providing Kk Room Finder For Happy Holidays! Please Visit my website.Thanks felicia harris book keepsake book

Benjamin James said...

hellow frieends plz give me your positive response on my website and i hope visit and enjoy our website Unfurnished Rooms For Rent in Bronx

Dream Covers said...

Hi i,am Selling Home Decors If you want a luxuries trendy look for your bedroom Online dreamcovers Bed Sheets.

Follow Our Website

Panthar Jackets said...

Custom Leather Jacket for Men & Women Online at the best price range, Customize your jacket or made to measure options available for all types of leather jackets

Panther Jackets For Men

Aussie Jackets said...

Are You Looking For Leather Jacket Store? Here is a Huge List of Men's & Women's Leather Jackets! Please Visit my website.Thanks

Women Jacket Australia